AI and the "Nonprofit Visibility Gap"


Hi friends ๐Ÿ‘‹๐Ÿป

This week, my take on a SSIR article about the "Nonprofit Visibility Gap" which is about ... surprise, surprise ... AI tools. Worth a read if you're worrying about losing donors to the changing landscape of search tools, and if you need to persuade leadership to invest in digital marketing as the search landscape changes.


Want links to recent emails or a sign-up link to share? Go to The Digital Landscape sign-up pageโ€‹


More thoughts on nonprofits and AI visibility

Last week I came across this article in SSIR:

This touches on one of the questions I'm getting asked the most when I'm working with clients on their websites and digital marketing strategies ... loosely paraphrased:

We see our traffic from Google going down and we're worried we're missing out on traffic coming from AI tools.

And specifically, some of that most important traffic: visits that lead to online donations.

It's worth a read, because while I think the argument how much search traffic has shifted to AI tools is a bit overblown, the advice it contains is still good!

Here's a quick version:

  • In the good old days (like 2+ years ago), a potential donor looking to give to a nonprofit in a certain cause area would have used a traditional search engine like Google to research orgs to give to. They would have clicked around, visited different sites, and done some thinking.
  • Today, in the new era of AI tools like ChatGPT and Claude, those same potential donors might go to one of those tools to do that same job. And here's the difference:

As you have probably observed, AI tools are far more likely to not just do research, but to provide you with a confident final answer.

In SSIR, the authors write:

Bypassing search, our donor consults AI chat interfaces [...] The answers differ slightly, but the tools converge on the same destination. [...] Both close with a version of the same line: โ€œIf I were making one donation, Iโ€™d make it this one.โ€

The argument is that instead of visiting several organization's websites and thinking about what kind of work they want to support in that cause area, a donor in a hurry might just choose to donate to the one org that ChatGPT recommends.

Herein lies the fear: what if that organization isn't yours?

And it's a reasonable fear โ€“ the research cited in the article indicates that the AI tools tend to converge around recommending the same general set of large, established nonprofit organizations in each cause area.

Which makes sense. The US social sector has almost 2 million nonprofit organizations, and those that have been around the longest, have the largest budgets, and have the most reach are likely to rise to the top of a large language model's citation decisions.

What isn't going to surface?

  • Small or new community-based organizations doing innovative work.
  • Organizations without the marketing budget to build an audience through an earned media campaign.
  • Organizations that haven't (yet) invested in a strong website and brand profile.

Temper that fear a bit

The authors of this article (or at least one of them, who is CEO of Giving Compass) are incentivized to build AI search into a new way that donors find nonprofits.

In reality, research suggests the shift is more nuanced.

For example, a study earlier this year indicated that while over a third of consumers might start their search with an AI tool, as many as 85% still check the AI tool's answers elsewhere! So the lack of trust in AI tool responses is real (as it should be).

And to add to the complexity, Google โ€“ the elephant in the search engines room โ€“ now blends AI with traditional search results in a way that makes search behavior increasingly difficult to parse out.

A potential donor might head to Google and start their research, but the first thing they see after searching is an AI-generated response, interrupting the traditional flow and potentially catching attention before the user sees your organization's website homepage as a traditional blue link in the results.

What should you do?

The authors of the SSIR article make some sensible suggestions, and I think they're a great place to start. Here they are, in brief:

  1. Keep your basic org info up to date and consistent. AI models will cross check basic organizational information across your website, Candid profile, Charity Navigator profile, IRS reports, and documents on your website like annual reports. Don't present conflicting data! Get those profiles claimed and cleaned up.
  2. Lean into optimizing third-party profiles. Claim your organization's profiles on Candid and Charity Navigator and fill out ALL the details. AI tools are leaning on these platforms to learn about your organization, especially when comparing your organization to others in the same space.
  3. Stay on message and be consistent. Spend time establishing clean, boilerplate messaging about your organization, what you do, your list of programs, your recent impact numbers, and then use that information everywhere you show up: in press releases, in media hits, at conferences, in publications ... Repetition and aligned communications give AI tools confidence in their responses (not that they're short on confidence already ...)
  4. Check in on AI tool responses. This is hard to do systematically, but you can open up an AI tool as a private user (without your chat history) and ask it about organizations in your cause area, or about your organization specifically. There's a link to a video in this recent email with some suggestions about how to do this.

I hope this helps as you're thinking about how to navigate this rapidly changing digital landscape in 2027.

Thoughts and questions are always welcome!


Until next time โœจ

โ€” Ed Harris (your digital strategy guide)

โ€‹

๐Ÿค” Have a question?

If you have a question about how to optimize your website or get more out of your digital marketing weโ€™ll do our best to help out. Hit reply and send us a message and weโ€™ll get in touch.

๐Ÿ”— Affiliate Disclosure

Some links to products or services in The Digital Landscape emails and on the Blue Hills Digital website are affiliate links. This means we may receive compensation in return for new customers we refer. We only recommend products and services we use and love, and this helps us fund the creation of educational content for subscribers like you!

โœ‹ Want to stop receiving these emails?

You're receiving this email because you signed up either at the Blue Hills Digital website, or on my personal site at edharris.me.

You can update your preferences or unsubscribe using the links below. No hard feelings!

โ€‹

โ€‹Unsubscribe ยท Preferences ยท 5331 S Macadam Ave, Ste 258 PMB 1090, Portland, OR 97239

Blue Hills Digital

A guide for nonprofit communications professionals & mission-driven marketers. Delivered weekly, by email.

Read more from Blue Hills Digital

Hi friends ๐Ÿ‘‹๐Ÿป Last week we saw thousands of candidates win elections across the country. A huge thank you to all the candidates, campaign teams, staff, and families that made the blue tsunami a reality ๐Ÿ’™๐Ÿ’™๐Ÿ’™ This week, I'm sharing some thoughts about what this means for nonprofit communications and advocacy teams as 2027 approaches. Want links to recent emails or a sign-up link to share? Go to The Digital Landscape sign-up page New lawmakers need education Now that we know who will be...

Hi friends ๐Ÿ‘‹๐Ÿป This week, a cautionary tale about a website hand-off that missed a critically important step, and a free tool you can use to check your own website. Want links to recent emails or a sign-up link to share? Go to The Digital Landscape sign-up page ๐Ÿ’ก The case of the invisible website Recently I received a question from a nonprofit communications manager at a small org where a volunteer had put together a new website. It had been a few months since the new website went live, and...

Hi friends ๐Ÿ‘‹๐Ÿป A quick tip this week: we're going to check how your Website homepage shows up when somebody shares the link on social media or in a messaging platform. I'll admit I messed this up when I redesigned the homepage of the Blue Hills Digital website a few months ago. The other day, I was demoing a tool that allows you to test the social link preview, and I was surprised by what I saw on my own website ๐Ÿ˜ฌ So, learn from my experience and go check your own homepage right now using the...